Friday, February 12, 2010

Green Police

Did you see the Audi Super Bowl commercial that satirically promoted the “Green Police” arresting people for using incandescent bulbs, requesting plastic bags, and not composting or recycling their trash?

The alarming thing is that those laws, aimed at forcing a cultural behavior change, aren’t satire. They already have a foothold in our country.

Three years ago San Francisco became the first major US city to ban plastic grocery bags. Ironically, the plastic bag was actually introduced as an environmentally friendly alternative to the paper bag to protect America’s forests from destruction. Last year San Francisco toughened up their mandatory recycling laws to include composting. That scene in the commercial where they’re going to arrest the guy for putting an orange peel in the garbage disposal? While you might not be arrested in San Francisco, you could be fined if you are found to be deliberately flouting the law. The current mayor of San Francisco actually twittered, “Ok .. That "green police" Audi commercial hits home..

Closer to home, this past Monday, I received a letter from my hometown stating that we are no longer allowed to use traditional plastic trash bags for our grass clippings or leaves. Instead, we may only use specially designed biodegradable bags bearing a seal of approval from the city. These bags cost twice as much as the decent garbage bags we currently use. Non-compliance will earn you a fine of $50 to $2,000.

I believe there’s a line between educating people on the many personal ways we can help our environment and encouraging or motivating them to be enthusiastic about participating versus passing laws mandating their behavior and forcing them to change.


  1. I LOVED the commercial - it was a hoot. We've actually looked at clean diesel cars in the past and it reminded us to keep them in mind.

    One of the cities we lived in made us buy those bags - if they are ripping you off that's something to take up with the city. That has nothing to do with recycling.

    My cousin lived in Germany and it was mandatory that you recycle there. They went through your trash.

    Sometimes we should be doing something as individuals to help the society as a whole. Littering is something that carries a fine now - I'm sure it didn't in the 60's. A humerous look at the extremes is a good way of raising our conciousness.

  2. The ad begins as a very funny satire. In the end, with the goal of selling their cars, we see it ultimately targeting those who accept the green police possessing a certain amount of moral authority. We should all be involved with common sense efforts to protect the environment, but the radicalism of many environmentalists tend to sway a lot of folks in the other direction.

    Speaking of the environment, we're snowed in here in Dallas. Where's Al Gore when we need him.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...